While, in the streaming era, there is never a shortage of movies and TV shows to get your heart racing, for those who prefer the thrill of a real-life story, the best true-crime shows deliver. And no need to limit your viewing to Criminal Minds or Law & Order , either—options from Ted Bundy: Falling for a Killer and The Keepers to the less-bloody-but-equally-thrilling Inventing Anna and Baby Reindeer abound. Read on for some of the best true-crime shows to add to your queue for your next night in.
Fanatical: The Catfishing of Tegan and Sara (2024) In the late ’90s and early 2000s, the indie rock duo Tegan and Sara—made up of twin sisters—rose to fame, performing everywhere from The Tonight Show with Jay Leno to Coachella. They cultivated a close-knit, passionate fan base online by leveraging the emerging social media platforms of the era to connect directly with their audience. However, their community—and the band itself—was profoundly shaken when a scammer stole Tegan’s identity and began forming fake relationships with fans.
This riveting Hulu documentary delves into the trauma of a 16-year-long catfishing ordeal, offering a compelling cautionary tale about the dangers of parasocial connections gone tragically wrong. Baby Reindeer (2024) The Netflix show that took 2024—and the internet—by storm, Baby Reindeer , revolves around the real-life story of a struggling comedian and bartender, Richard Gadd, targeted by a female stalker named Martha ( Jessica Gunn.
