Star of Real Housewives of Salt Lake City Heather Gay is confusing fans after she recently changed up her story about former co-star Jen Shah giving her a black eye. Heather, who recently confirmed losing weight due to using Ozempic, and who has expressed interest in hosting a Secret Lives of Mormon Wives Reunion, has been open about moments on the show — including how the cast bonded over Monica Garcia’s firing. However, one thing that has consistently confused fans has been the way she has addressed the black eye she received during the show’s Season 3 cast trip.
At the time, she continued to insist that Jen wasn’t the one responsible for it, as she kept defending her even after her legal troubles surfaced. However, she then shared on the show’s Season four finale that Jen was the one responsible–though she has since changed her story yet again. After admitting on the finale that she got the black eye from Jen after a night of heavy drinking, and only knew it came from Jen when the other woman told her she did it, she also shared she didn't know how it happened.
However, now, according to the Los Angeles Times , she claims she doesn’t actually remember what happened. “Gay’s allegiance to Shah was so blind, she even refused to say how she’d ended up with a black eye after a night of partying in San Diego,” writer Meredith Blake said in the new interview with the publication. “She dodged questions for months; then in the Season 4 finale, alleged that S.
