Recent K-dramas are using one-night stands as a theme, drawing criticism from some viewers. Captured from SBS One-night stands in dramas draw criticism for potentially harmful messages By KTimes Recent dramas such as "Good Partner" and "My Sweet Mobster" have ignited controversy for their portrayal of one-night stands, with some viewers questioning whether these scenes are necessary, especially when they disrupt the established identity of the characters. In "My Sweet Mobster," for example, a character unexpectedly becomes pregnant after a one-night stand, leaving viewers puzzled.
Given that both shows are rated for viewers 15 and older, concerns have been raised about the potential for these portrayals to instill unhealthy sexual values. Two popular dramas have recently addressed the topic of one-night stands in different ways. In episode 4 of SBS's "Good Partner," characters Han Yu-ri (played by Nam Ji-hyun) and her lawyer colleague Jeon Eun-ho (played by Pyo Ji-hoon) end up spending a night together after a heavy drinking session.
The scene, however, failed to convince viewers, who found it inconsistent with Han Yuri's character. Throughout the series, Han Yu-ri was portrayed as deeply affected by her father's infidelity, leading her to be skeptical of marriage and relationships. Her sudden decision to spend the night with Jeon Eun-ho, whom she previously viewed more as a friend than a romantic interest, felt out of character, leading to criticism from viewers.
The poster for SBS TV drama, "Good Partner" / Courtesy of SBS Freedom of expression Comments on the SBS YouTube channel included remarks like, "This is so outdated. The scene of two people waking up together in a motel is so cliché," and "Does it make sense for a character who has a strong aversion to relationships with men to have a one-night stand?" Similarly, in JTBC's "My Sweet Mobster," Mi-ho (played by Moon Ji-in) suddenly spends the night with Il-young (played by Kim Hyun-jin), leading to an unexpected pregnancy and subsequent marriage. Il-young confesses that he only began to like Mi-ho after learning about the pregnancy.
According to the Korea Communications Commission’s regulations, section 35 on sexual expression stipulates that broadcasts should not focus primarily on immoral or unhealthy relationships. Additionally, the 15+ rating from the Korea Media Rating Board means that the content should be appropriate for teenagers without distorting their sexual perceptions. While indirect or implied sexual expressions that do not directly contradict social ethics are allowed, the repeated depiction of one-night stands in dramas may create a sense of deja vu for viewers.
While societal views on sex have broadened, and the concept of sexuality has evolved, the frequent use of one-night stands as a plot device in dramas can be concerning. For instance, the ongoing KBS2 drama "Beauty and Mr. Romantic" also briefly features a storyline where two characters spend the night together after a chance meeting.
The poster for JTBC's drama, "My Sweet Mobster" / Courtesy of JTBC Teetering on edge of acceptability In the OTT (over-the-top) streaming space, such themes are even more common, with shows like Tving's "Work Later, Drink Now" and Netflix's "Love to Hate You" often highlighting sexually liberated and independent female characters. Ironically, all of the mentioned dramas feature female protagonists who are portrayed as leading proactive and ambitious lives. In "Good Partner," for example, the story focuses on a young lawyer growing into her role and developing a healthy understanding of marriage, which makes the sudden introduction of a one-night stand difficult to justify.
Although one-night stands have been a theme in past dramas, there seems to be a growing trend in their portrayal. While such content may reflect certain aspects of social reality, it also teeters on the edge of acceptability. The potential for negative impact on teenagers, who are in the process of forming their sexual values, is particularly concerning.
It's worth noting that after smoking was removed from public broadcast, smoking rates decreased among both teenagers and adults. While one-night stands are not illegal, they do not necessarily contribute to a healthy broadcasting culture. This highlights the need for producers to carefully consider the implications of such content.
This article from the Hankook Ilbo, a sister publication of The Korea Times, is translated by a generative AI and edited by staff of The Korea Times..
