Bikie clubs (roughly speaking, social clubs that have a slot on the org chart for a sergeant-at-arms) are the political equivalent of pro wrestling "heels" - the Iron Sheik, the Undertaker, larger-than-life theatrically gifted evildoers whose function is to be booed while making the hero look good. or signup to continue reading Nobody has a good word to say about them, and they'd feel insulted if anyone did. I'll say this for bikie gangs, though: their clubhouses don't have poker machines.
That's one form of harm where they come out well ahead of your average RSL. And there are a lot more RSLs than there are bikie clubs. We know that - lots and lots of it.
I'd give examples, except that it'd be fairly pointless because nobody actually attempts to deny it. We've just decided, collectively, to shrug our shoulders and look the other way. Against this, clubs with pokies are heavily taxed and contribute buckets of money to the government's bottom line.
In addition, they're supposed to balance out some of the harm they do to the local community by returning a chunk of the takings (in Victoria, for example, 8.33 per cent) in the form of donations to "community benefit". And when I say "local", that's a straightforward geographic expression: one study found that "people who live closer to pokies venues are more likely to gamble and are more likely to experience serious financial and mental health consequences", which is not, as far as I know, true of bikie clubhouses.
Before your domestic violence charity approaches the club down the road seeking a contribution to its women's refuge, though, you should be warned that the vast majority of clubs have the firm view that charity begins at home. A report from the Alliance for Gambling Reform (AGR) found that 77 per cent of clubs, after considering all possible recipients, had realised that the most worthy object of this money was in fact themselves. Last year Victorian clubs spent $241.
7 million on "staff wages, staff meals, beer gas, venue decorations, security, pay TV subscriptions, accounting, legal fees, council rates, pest control, trophies and prizes for members" (and if you want to check, you can go to the website of the Victorian Casino and Gambling Control Commission and search for " " to look up what your favourite venue has reported). We are community groups, the clubs say: we serve the community, and we deserve a break. In an era where at all that can't be handled on a smartphone there is something in this.
It's also true that clubs use these savings to subsidise drinks and meals and attract more patrons for their gaming rooms, providing more unfortunates for the meatgrinder. The Victorian government has responded to the AGR report by saying it's shocked - shocked! - to find that gambling is going on here, while of course pocketing its winnings. Money doesn't stink, as the Roman emperor Vespasian once remarked (he was taxing urine - hey, there's an idea!).
Isn't it better to tax heavily the things that we want to discourage - gambling, drinking and smoking - than the things we want to encourage, like payrolls (or urination)? The flaw in this argument is that getting 10 per cent of the state budget from gambling taxes does rather discourage governments from actually discouraging these vices. Gambling has grown around the institutions of Australian society - its sports, its associations, its entertainments - to the point where it's hard to cut back the growth without killing the patient. That's the defence the : free-to-air television has become dependent on it, and sports depend on TV rights.
It's the same argument that the tobacco companies ran with for so long last century - without tobacco sponsorship, sports would go broke and wither away. We were, as a society, able to fight back against that by simply taxing cigarettes directly and passing the money directly to footballers and cricketers through targeted public sector sponsorships. Why don't we do that now? Times change - bikie clubs, for example, are now subject to generally applicable smoking bans, and their members (though not, again, the actual clubs as business entities) seem to be putting their effort into bootleg tobacco over the traditional harder drugs.
We face new challenges, and old problems, and we want governments that try to fix them rather than just booing the villain. Bikie clubs are the poster, not the problem. DAILY DURING PARALYMPICS Get the best news and analysis from the Paris Paralympic Games in a daily update.
DAILY Today's top stories curated by our news team. WEEKLY The latest news, results & expert analysis. WEEKLY Get the editor's insights: what's happening & why it matters.
WEEKLY Love footy? We've got all the action covered. WEEKLY Every Sunday explore destinations, deals, tips & travel writing to transport you around Australia and the globe. WEEKLY Going out or staying in? Find out what's on.
WEEKDAYS Sharp. Close to the ground. Digging deep.
Your weekday morning newsletter on national affairs, politics and more. TWICE WEEKLY Your essential national news digest: all the big issues on Wednesday and great reading every Saturday. WEEKLY Get news, reviews and expert insights every Thursday from CarExpert, ACM's exclusive motoring partner.
TWICE WEEKLY Get real, Australia! Let the ACM network's editors and journalists bring you news and views from all over. AS IT HAPPENS Be the first to know when news breaks. DAILY Your digital replica of Today's Paper.
Ready to read from 5am! DAILY Test your skills with interactive crosswords, sudoku & trivia. Fresh daily! Advertisement Advertisement.
