To fix the Silent Hill 2 jukebox in Neely's Bar you'll need to find a broken record, glue, a coin and a button. What makes this potentially confusing is that you can find the four elements in any order. And, while finding the jukebox explains everything else, if you do what I did and find all the other bits first, you might not know what you're meant to be doing.
Even once have everything, there's still a little puzzle to solve before you can get everything working. After the Silent Hill 2 Remake Auto Parts key and Grand Market keypad code you solved to get here, this is the first 'real' multisection puzzle to get stuck into so here's how to find everything you need to fix the Neely's Bar jukebox in Silent Hill 2. Silent Hill 2 Neely's Bar Matchbook You'll find the Neely's Bar matchbox in Martin Street, just after you fight your first monster, which will mark the bar on your map.
While you're free to explore anywhere at this point, the bar will be your eventual goal and a bottleneck you must pass though to continue the story. How to find the jukebox parts in Silent Hill 2 Once you've found Neely's Bar in Silent Hill 2 you'll find a jukebox under a sheet inside. When you try and use it, it will break and present you with half a record.
On the bar you'll find a note that will talk about the record being broken, a missing button, and that the person responsible ran towards Groovy Music record store and lives in Saul Apartments. To fix and use the jukebox in Silent Hill 2 you'll .