Even before Georgia Outlaw met her new nephrologist, she had made her decision: Although her kidneys were failing, she didn’t want to begin dialysis. Outlaw, 77, a retired social worker and pastor in Williamston, N.C.
, knew many relatives and friends with advanced kidney disease. She watched them travel to dialysis centers three times a week, month after month, to spend hours having waste and excess fluids flushed from their blood. “They’d come home weak and tired and go to bed,” she said.
“It’s a day until they feel back to normal, and then it’s time to go back to dialysis again. I didn’t want that regimen.” She told her doctors, “I’m not going to spend my days bound to some procedure that’s not going to extend my life or help me in any way.
” Outlaw was mistaken on one point — dialysis can prolong the lives of patients with kidney failure. But a new study published in the journal Annals of Internal Medicine analyzed data from a simulated trial involving records from more than 20,000 older patients (average age: about 78) in the Veterans Health Administration system. It found that their survival gains were “modest.
” How modest? Over three years, older patients with kidney failure who started dialysis right away lived for an average of 770 days — just 77 days longer than those who never started it. “I think people would find that surprising,” said Dr. Manjula Tamura, a nephrologist and researcher at Stanford University and a senior author .
