Monday, September 9, 2024 As leaders in Indonesia prepare to introduce new legislation aimed at regulating tourism development within the province, business owners in the tourism sector are turning to international travel destinations for insights on managing the challenges of overtourism. With South Bali nearing the tipping point of overcapacity, these local businesses are keen to adopt best practices from other global hotspots that have successfully mitigated the negative impacts of mass tourism. By studying these models, they hope to strike a balance between fostering economic growth and preserving the cultural and environmental integrity of the region.
South Bali’s struggle with overtourism mirrors the experiences of many iconic travel destinations around the world, where high visitor numbers have led to overcrowding and resource depletion. These destinations offer valuable lessons on sustainable tourism practices, from implementing visitor caps to promoting off-peak travel and diversifying tourist attractions. Business owners and policymakers alike recognize that these shared experiences can pave the way for more thoughtful and sustainable tourism development in Bali, ensuring long-term benefits for the local economy and the preservation of the island’s natural beauty.
The historic Belgian city of Bruges has implemented a fresh policy aimed at curbing the growing number of short-term vacation rentals within its city center. This new regulation is designed to protect the character of the city’s heritage sites by limiting the spread of such properties, which have surged in recent years due to increasing tourist demand. In addition to targeting vacation rentals, the policy also places restrictions on the development of new hotels within the city.
Bruges officials are taking proactive steps to manage the sharp rise in tourism, hoping to prevent potential long-term issues associated with overcrowding and to preserve the city’s cultural and historical integrity for future generations. In 2023, Bruges saw an influx of over 8.2 million tourists, a staggering number compared to the city’s modest population of just 120,000 residents.
This surge in visitors has placed immense pressure on the city’s infrastructure, echoing challenges faced by other major European destinations such as Venice and Barcelona, where overtourism has started to erode the quality of life for locals. The overcrowding has led to concerns about the sustainability of the tourism sector, as the charm and heritage that attract visitors may be at risk of being compromised by the sheer volume of people. This issue is not unique to Bruges, as Bali experiences similar struggles.
Bali residents, for instance, are often caught in hours of tourism-related traffic, making it difficult to go about their daily lives. The overwhelming number of tourists has led to congestion and other adverse impacts on local communities. The growing frustration among residents in both regions highlights the need for balanced tourism strategies that can protect the interests of locals while continuing to support the economy, ensuring that both the residents and the visitors can enjoy what these destinations have to offer.
Unlike many of Bali’s largest resorts, Bruges attracts a significant influx of daytrippers. These short-term visitors flood the city for brief stays, contributing to overcrowding without the benefits of extended tourism spending. These concerns will strongly resonate with both leaders and residents in Bali, where discussions around new strategies to manage overtourism are gaining momentum.
As the island continues to face similar challenges with overcrowding, local authorities are exploring ways to preserve the region’s cultural and environmental integrity while maintaining its status as a top tourist destination. The urgency for effective solutions is evident as the strain on infrastructure and quality of life for residents becomes more pronounced. Residents, in particular, are feeling the effects of these challenges, as daily life is increasingly disrupted by tourism-related issues like traffic congestion and the overuse of public spaces.
Bali’s leadership is keenly aware of these pressures and is working to implement policies that address the growing number of visitors without sacrificing the island’s unique appeal. The lessons learned from other popular destinations, such as Bruges, may provide valuable insights as Bali seeks to strike a sustainable balance between tourism and local well-being. Earlier this week, Indonesia’s Minister of Tourism and Creative Economies announced that he is drafting new legislation aimed at preventing the further conversion of agricultural and community-owned land in Bali into tourism developments and commercial properties.
This move is part of the government’s broader effort to safeguard the island’s cultural heritage and protect its natural landscapes from unchecked development. Despite the introduction of a tourism tax in February 2024, Bali’s leaders have faced challenges in ensuring that all visitors comply with the mandatory contribution. Reports suggest that as many as 60% of international tourists have failed to pay the Bali Tourism Tax Levy.
In response, the Bali Tourism Office has begun conducting routine spot checks to ensure compliance, as these funds are essential for preserving the island’s cultural and natural beauty while improving tourism infrastructure. Minister Uno, along with other tourism leaders, is committed to promoting the lesser-explored areas of Bali, particularly in the northern, western, and eastern parts of the island. Their goal is to alleviate the heavy tourism concentration in the southern resort areas by encouraging visitors to discover these underappreciated regions, thereby spreading the benefits of tourism more evenly across the island.
Minister Uno confirmed that the central government has approved plans for a new toll road running through the center of Bali. This infrastructure project aims to support sustainable tourism development by improving accessibility to less-visited regions of the island, helping to balance growth and reduce pressure on the more concentrated southern areas. Indonesia has recently entered into agreements with several of Africa’s leading tourism nations to collaborate on developing long-term sustainable tourism models.
This partnership aims to exchange ideas and strategies for fostering responsible tourism growth while protecting natural and cultural resources. As more cities and popular travel destinations worldwide propose solutions to the issue of overtourism, Bali is likely to evaluate these approaches carefully. The island is expected to consider a range of strategies to manage its own tourism challenges while ensuring sustainability for the future.
.
