Rumors of a Rutger McGroarty (drafted 14th overall in 2022) trade were going around as early as the NHL Draft back in June, when it was confirmed by Winnipeg Jets GM Kevin Cheveldayoff that forward McGroarty had no intention of signing with the Jets. When no trade materialized, the assumption became that McGroarty would return to the University of Michigan for his junior season. When he was traded to the Pittsburgh Penguins for Moose Jaw Warriors forward Brayden Yager (drafted 14th overall in 2023), however, he immediately signed his entry-level contract with the Penguins.
People like to talk about trades in terms of winners and losers. Looking at it through that lens, it could be argued that the Penguins are the clear winners here. Contrary to what more extreme discussions would have you believe, though, that doesn't make the trade a loss for the Jets.
They were in a tough spot with McGroarty refusing to sign, and, per remarks from Cheveldayoff, not giving a specific reason other than that it "didn't feel right". Often when this happens with NCAA players, lack of leverage makes it difficult for teams to get any significant return for the player and sometimes they end up having to let the player walk for nothing after they finish their college career. The Jets getting Yager, who has potential, is a relative win for them in a difficult situation.
Bottom line? The Penguins got something they needed: a sharp young forward who can contribute now. The Jets also got something they .