A Massachusetts man finally won back the $70,000 Tiffany's engagement ring he gave to his cheating partner after seven years. Appealing his initial case, when Bruce Johnson, 67, took teacher Caroline Settino, 59, to court over his proposal to her after he found salacious messages on her phone to another man, Johnson has now won the war. The Massachusetts court first ruled in favor of Johnson’s fiancée Settino, saying the man “mistakenly thought she was cheating on him.
” READ MORE: Memphis woman 'shoots at family in mall parking lot from her car after argument' READ MORE: Man 'blames karma for 2-year-old's death when police make horror discovery' READ MORE: Parents 'brutally murder each other' as 11-year-old son plays in the next room READ MORE: Bigfoot heard 'screaming and whooping' in popular Connecticut Sasquatch hotspot Johnson said he looked through his partner’s phone and found a message to another man saying “My Bruce is going to be in Connecticut for three days. I need some playtime.” However, in September the case was taken to the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, which ruled on Friday Johnson should keep the ring.
The pair initially fell apart almost a decade ago in 2016, when, after a period of Johnson spoiling the teacher with luxury holidays to New York and Italy and expensive gifts, trouble in paradise ensued. In November 2017, he gave her the $70,000 Tiffany diamond engagement ring and two sparkling wedding bands for another $3,700. Following t.