Emmerdale viewers are convinced they've figured out who Caleb Milligan's (played by Will Ash) mysterious daughter Stephanie is and she could be right under their noses in the village. Ever since the mention of Caleb's daughter, avid followers have been on edge trying to identify her and pondering if she will pop up in the village. One vigilant fan of the ITV soap believes she might actually be an unexpected resident.

In recent episodes, Caleb was seen visiting Ruby's (Beth Cordingly) ailing mum Helen at the hospital, where the situation escalated rapidly as he coerced her, demanding cash in return for letting her meet her daughter before passing away. The conversation between Caleb and Helen, Ruby's estranged mother, suggested secrets yet unveiled, particularly as viewers are aware Caleb and Ruby share a son, Nicky Milligan (Lewis Cope), who has left town. Helen revealed her urgent wish during their exchange: "My daughter has a right to know that I am dying," underscoring the urgency of mending family rifts ahead of time's end, reports Leeds Live .

Caleb's resentment was palpable when confronting Helen: "I know you paid me to ditch her and I know when she got pregnant, you tried to force her to abort our child and I know you turfed her out with nothing and she wouldn't." The remorse from Ruby's mother was clear as she confessed the guilt of her past actions: "I have had to live with that my entire life," only to be met with Caleb's cutting response: "And now you'll have to di.