Brooke first met her husband Noah in a youth group for the Greater Grand Rapids, Michigan, school district in 2017 — or so she thought Brooke Krupiczewicz first met her husband Noah in a youth group for the Greater Grand Rapids, Michigan, school district around 2017 — or so she thought. The Michigan natives had grown up in neighboring towns near Grand Rapids: Brooke, 24, was from Granville, and Noah, 25, was raised just south in Byron Center. They began dating while they were seniors in high school and, a few years later, got married.

One day, after the couple learned they were expecting a daughter, they were going through their baby books and memory boxes when Brooke noticed something strange. "I recognized all these kids Noah was in preschool with, and then he recognized a bunch from my class," Brooke tells PEOPLE exclusively. Brooke Krupiczewicz Related: Puzzled, Brooke called her parents to find out more about her preschool class.

She knew she'd attended preschool in the afternoon, while Noah had gone in the morning. However, the couple had never discussed their preschool experiences. Later that day, her parents sent her a video of her preschool graduation, which included all of the students from both the morning and afternoon classes — and it all clicked.

"Sure enough, Noah was two rows behind me," Brooke says. "It was so strange that we were that close to each other and now we're married." "It was such an odd moment.

It made us wonder how many times in our lives w.