Dancing With the Stars fans are pretty certain they’re going to see a member of Bachelor Nation on the show’s upcoming 33rd season–but it may not be someone they’re expecting after a possible shocking clue. Fresh off the heels of the show announcing Olympian Stephen Nedoroscik as the first celebrity , the ABC show also announced that the full cast reveal would be coming on Sept. 4–just under two weeks prior to the season premiere.

Fans have been leveraging guesses for months on the likely competitors , and many have seemed agreed that someone from The Bachelor universe would be on the show, as it is often customary to bring someone in since the two shows are from the same network. DWTS full cast announcement date after US Olympian joins new season Derek Hough shows off his toned hysique after confirming his DWTS return However, many were convinced it could be Golden Bachelor Gerry Turner , Bachelor Season 29 star Joey Graziadei or current Bachelorette Jenn Tran . But a new preview has some fans wondering if the show is hinting that someone from a different season of the show would actually be coming on instead.

In a new Instagram preview advertising Jenn Tran’s upcoming Men Tell All special, Jenn wasn’t the person featured–Rachel Recchia, who was the Season 19 co-lead with Gabby Windey, was. “The ghost with the most is looking for another bride-to-be. Don’t miss Jenn’s Men Tell All episode of #TheBachelorette on ABC and Stream on Hulu to see what @pilot.

.